Skip to main content

Chapters 3 & 4

 Trauma is overwhelming. Reading about it, learning about it, experiencing it - all overwhelming. The amount of knowledge and experience that Van Der Kolk has is also overwhelming for this second-semester graduate student who still trying to distinguish the responsibilities of all the different brain structures. Chapter 3 was interesting to read as the trauma scripts were reinvented as participants essentially volunteered to relive their trauma's. Marsha's story was hard to read about as I can't imagine and pain, guilt, and fear that could come from losing your children in an instant. Through Marsha's story, I was better able to recognize and understand how diverse and individualistic triggers can be. To some - parents fighting and loud noises might be a trigger and yet to others, such as Marsha, the sound of children laughing. I wondered, ethically, if this procedure was okay and I was pleased to see that Van Der Kolk also questioned this as well. 

Reading about Broca's area was something new to me and how this affects speech and how without this area, one cannot put thoughts and feelings into words. Furthermore, it was interesting to read how the "scans showed that Broca's area went offline whenever a flashback was triggered" (p.43). This can affect people even years after the trauma as they may be unable to articulately express what happened to them. I wonder about my five-year client who was been through significant trauma. I wonder about her future and I wonder if I even know the full extent of the trauma, or if I only know the cover story. The amount of trauma this sweet girl as gone through is more than anyone at her age should go through. It saddens me to acknowledge the fact more trauma is to come as another disruption looms over her family and the possibility of a removal is present.  It wouldn't be the first time she would be removed from her mother’s care and I wonder what kind of behavior we might see, will she freeze? Or will she scream, hit, spit, and use profanities like she has before. 

Chapter 4 tells the story of young Noam Saul and how he witnessed the traumatic events of 9/11. His drawing of the event, including the trampoline, is thoughtful and creative. It reminds me of having childlike faith. While the events that he witnessed were horrific, his addition of the trampoline was innocent and pure in a way. Noam and my sweet five-year-old girl are different. Noam, though he experienced something traumatic, was surrounded by love and what he witnessed - it came to an end. However, my sweet client lives in chaos day in and day out. The text states on page 53, " during disasters young children usually take their cues from their parents. As long as their caregivers remain calm and responsive to their needs, the often survive terrible incidents without serious psychological scars". Her trauma, I fear, may not come to an end in such a way as Noam's did. 


Comments

  1. Mariah,

    What happened to your client? Was she removed? Has she responded to any type of therapy yet? I continue to be interested in the information we learn about the brain as it relates to trauma. I truly believe the more we learn, the better our interventions can be to help people. Unfortunately, we can't have our clients have a real quick brain scan before they begin therapy. I enjoy reading about the different types of trauma endure and how it impacts people. You have such a tragic event such as 9/11 and then a woman loses her child. You can't compare the events, but you can compare the suffering of the person impacted by the trauma.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm sure there's a reason you're in that little girl's life. That is one thing that I will always remember about working directly with trauma victims, that feeling of anger and frustration that these things should not happen to these kids. If we can get them care early we give them a chance. Thanks for writing.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Chapters 19 & 20

 Van Der Kolks discussion and research on neuroscience was incredibly interesting, but I must admit that I got lost throughout this chapter. The medical abbreviations, methods, and research frequently went above my head. I did find his discussion on sleep at the beginning of this chapter more understandable and how even when we sleep, our internal communication is still wide awake. I wondered how those patients felt about having to wake up post REM sleep and if being startled could have changed any remembrance of the dream. While I understand that they knew about the research and therefore knew they would be awakened, I still wonder if it was shocking to suddenly be pulled from your sleep - especially if the dream that had occurred was pleasant. The entire concept of the brain and what it tells us is amazing to me. From discoveries like epilepsy and other mental activities to understanding how EEG patterns can be a biomarker for ADHD.  To sum up this section, Van Der Kolk stat...

Chapters 9 & 10

       These chapters, yet again, have reinforced why the work we do is important. Page 138 stated, " such patients typically receive five or six different unrelated diagnoses in the course of their psychiatric treatment" and page 139 further expands by stating that " none of these diagnoses will be completely off the mark, and none of them will begin to meaningfully describe who these patients are and what they suffer from". Children with a mental diagnosis are much more than a statistic.      I both enjoyed reading about and was taken aback by the formation of the DSM and how that diagnostical instrument came into 'power'. How what once was used for insurance companies is now the means of creating a lifelong label on someone. The stigma of having a diagnosis is something that one may carry with them all through life - from childhood to adulthood. Some may even identify as their diagnoses as the book describes a patient describing themselves as bipola...

Chapters 11 & 12

     These chapters were heavy as they discussed components of sexual abuse and trauma, particularly how it can affect memory. The story of Julian is something that I can't imagine going through - the idea of hearing about a story and having startling memories of the same thing happening to you must be hard. Even harder yet, trying to have an intimate moment with a girlfriend and suddenly experiencing a flashback must also be hard as feelings of shame, fear, or even guilt may begin to creep in. Later in the chapter, Van Der Kolk states that due to traumatic experiences, narratives are not always organized in a coherent way.      I did find it interesting to read about memories and just how greatly trauma can affect those memories - both good and bad. Van Der Kolk states, "whether we remember a particular event at all, and how accurate our memories of it are, largely depends on how personally meaningful it was and how emotional we felt about it at the...